I have one and like it. Couldn't get a brown sound out of it but got some great modern hi gain stuff. Was my favourite pedal until I got a BE-OD. BE-OD is a little "sweeter" to my ears. 5150 is still a great pedal though. I kept both.

 

I have one as well and like it a lot. I've thought about trying out a BE-OD but from the demos I've heard, it's a bit too 'mid-rangey' for my taste.

 

That BE-OD looks interesting. Going to have to watch some vids. What does the 'tight' knob do? Is it like sag?
While watching some That Pedal Show vids I saw them demo a Keeley 1962x pedal. I thought it sounded very good. Marshall style but not as hi gain as the 5150.

 

Here's a link to one of the better 'in-depth' videos I've seen.

As for the gain, I think they explain it in the video that the BE-OD has an internal trim pot that can have it go from mild od all the way to quite high gain.

 

Tbh I thought that video demo sounded like a bag of wasps - and I am a high gain freak. Very buzzy and 'pointy' with no body. I bet the pedal sounded better 'in the room'

 

After sifting through about a dozen diff't demos I kind of came to the same conclusion. The one I posted was one of the few that really went through what each of the knobs does. It also kind of cooled my (slight) obsession with getting distortion pedals. After a while they really do sound kind of similar, it's just a matter of how each one is eq'ed and options that are included.

Being that I already have a couple processors as well as some vst plugins, dropping $300 + on a pedal would be a bit redundant.

 

If you like it, keep it.

 

Has a built in noise gate that is optional not something I have really used much before. Although I found it odd that it takes longer to kick in with single coils.

Noisegates operate according to a threshold signal level.
Buckers usually have a stronger signal level than singles.

 

I bought the Bogner Red pedal based on this review. It has great body and tone with a boost.

The pedal is on my board and is fantastic. I also have a Fulltone OCD for lighter distortion and boost to amps' crunch channels.

Cheers,
Jim

 

Or check out this one:

 

As for the gain, I think they explain it in the video that the BE-OD has an internal trim pot that can have it go from mild od all the way to quite high gain.

I am not a fan of internal trim pots - I like to be able to adjust the pedal with knobs on the front that are easily accessible.

@sorbz62 - I have a bogner red pedal on my board and it has become my fave distortion pedal ( an I have tried many over 30 years of playing). It seems to have the most natural 'crunch' - you can get nice high gain sounds with it but it seems to retain definition better than any high gain crunch

I am very intrigued by the EVH 5150 pedal - the price is what's holding me back right now...it's $280 at L & M before taxes...ouch! =(

 

I am not a fan of internal trim pots - I like to be able to adjust the pedal with knobs on the front that are easily accessible.

@sorbz62 - I have a bogner red pedal on my board and it has become my fave distortion pedal ( an I have tried many over 30 years of playing). It seems to have the most natural 'crunch' - you can get nice high gain sounds with it but it seems to retain definition better than any high gain crunch

I am very intrigued by the EVH 5150 pedal - the price is what's holding me back right now...it's $280 at L & M before taxes...ouch! =(

I have the Bogner Red as well but being a 'metal' guy, I kind of prefer the 5150 slightly more than the Red, despite it being more versatile. That being said though, the Red does sound phenomenal when I use it for a drive pedal with my bass rig.

The thing about the price of the 5150, while there's always a chance of snagging a used one off Reverb or E-Bay, when you look at the other distortion pedals L&M have, the 5150 is probably one of the better sounding ones and has a noise gate. The only other one I could possibly recommend that's less than $300 and has a built in noise gate would be the Truetone Jekyll & Hyde but it has a bit more 'fizz' to it than the 5150 does.

 

Agree about the trim pots. P.I.T.A!!!
Also, in regards to the pricing, when I did the trade I looked into the 5150. It sells for $199 usd same as the Velvet fuzz that I traded for it. The Velvet sells for $240 cdn. As you said the 5150 is $280. And for comparison the Catalinbread SFT is $179usd/$240cdn. I don't know, maybe Brian is just being nice to us.