troyhead· Premium Member
Buy one of these, make your own plastic
This isn’t what the OP was recalling looking for, but I do have one of these and they are kind of fun. You have to file down the edges of the picks to make them smooth, otherwise they aren’t even comfortable to hold.A buddy got one of those, and the picks from it scratched the hell out of my pick guard. I'll never use one again.
For the record, I found that most credit cards and gift cards make terrible picks. The only ones I liked were the glossy gift cards from Starbucks, which makes a decent “medium” pick (the matte cards didn’t feel right to me).