Joined
·
13,370 Posts
Any musician whose music is unique enough to be considered almost a genre unto themselves.
One that comes to mind for me is Frank Zappa.
One that comes to mind for me is Frank Zappa.
Is there any musician who is a genre unto themselves.
1 - 20 of 42 Posts
Joined
·
18,586 Posts
I am told that no man is an island but when I play, that's where I should be; on a lonely island.
Joined
·
13,370 Posts
Brian made me think of Robert Fripp.
There are some, but they'll likely be somewhere in the realm of "serious music" (what some call "classical") or jazz. If they have a recording contract with a label that doesn't specialize in oddballs, then chances are pretty good they have that contract because they're like some other artist or reflect a particular existing genre.
There are certainly one-offs in the jazz guitar world, like Stanley Jordan, or Sonny Sharrock. Even Frank Zappa, as unique a voice as he was, borrowed heavily from others. The Absolutely Free album lifted considerable passages from Stravinsky and Holst, among others.
If one wishes to be popular, you're going to have some elements that are familiar to your intended audience. I thought Prince was pretty distinctive, but took plenty from others who came before him, and had plenty of contemporaries who emulated him. So as much as I liked him, and considered him a creative force, it would be very hard to classify him as a "genre unto himself".
There are certainly one-offs in the jazz guitar world, like Stanley Jordan, or Sonny Sharrock. Even Frank Zappa, as unique a voice as he was, borrowed heavily from others. The Absolutely Free album lifted considerable passages from Stravinsky and Holst, among others.
If one wishes to be popular, you're going to have some elements that are familiar to your intended audience. I thought Prince was pretty distinctive, but took plenty from others who came before him, and had plenty of contemporaries who emulated him. So as much as I liked him, and considered him a creative force, it would be very hard to classify him as a "genre unto himself".
Joined
·
1,892 Posts
Joined
·
4,105 Posts
Tough one...Jeff Beck(?). I was listening to the track "Nadia" last night and besides being mind boggling, it combines blues, middle eastern/tabla with techno music. He did a few albums in that same vein starting with Who Else in the late '90's. I thought it was a new genre in itself but not sure....
Joined
·
2,461 Posts
This guy's playing the Horseshoe tomorrow night.
Chuck Prophet & The Mission Express - Tickets - The Horseshoe Tavern - Toronto, ON, March 21, 2017 | Ticketfly
Joined
·
3,908 Posts
Captain Beefheart
Devo
Sufjan Stevens
Mike Oldfield
...for starters.
And Zappa for sure no matter how many influences he listed on "Freak Out".
Devo
Sufjan Stevens
Mike Oldfield
...for starters.
And Zappa for sure no matter how many influences he listed on "Freak Out".
Joined
·
7,207 Posts
OH My god..
Joined
·
8,744 Posts
I've never heard that before - that's a fantastic tune.
Joined
·
4,105 Posts
Yep, the first time I heard it I was totally blown away. Actually, it still blows me away. Beck being Beck, it's hard to distinguish which parts are bottleneck and not.
Isn't there another thread recently about Henry Kaiser that would qualify? Lol.
How about "Listener"? I remember this guy from just over a decade ago. Played tiny shows for 20 people. Best part was his shows doubled as a bring your own food buffet where and he just chilled with everyone before and after the show. At the time he was really struggling to invent a whole new music genre he called "talk music". Not much rhythm to the vocals and no real rhyming, sections, or patterns to speak of. More like essays spoken passionately over background music. Even background music can be a stretch for some songs. If I remember correctly, one "song" just had a girl pounding a washing machine with an axe that was wrapped in towels. This thread made me think of him and look him up again. Holy crap, some of his stuff now has 500k+ views on YouTube.
I would call them a genre unto themselves. Others would argue they are not a music act but a performance piece. Love it or hate it, it's definitely unique.
How about "Listener"? I remember this guy from just over a decade ago. Played tiny shows for 20 people. Best part was his shows doubled as a bring your own food buffet where and he just chilled with everyone before and after the show. At the time he was really struggling to invent a whole new music genre he called "talk music". Not much rhythm to the vocals and no real rhyming, sections, or patterns to speak of. More like essays spoken passionately over background music. Even background music can be a stretch for some songs. If I remember correctly, one "song" just had a girl pounding a washing machine with an axe that was wrapped in towels. This thread made me think of him and look him up again. Holy crap, some of his stuff now has 500k+ views on YouTube.
I would call them a genre unto themselves. Others would argue they are not a music act but a performance piece. Love it or hate it, it's definitely unique.
Joined
·
4,105 Posts
The haunting Steel lines were gorgeous - I enjoyed that.
Joined
·
5,628 Posts
Indeed. And I don't think anyone has mentioned Glenn Branca yet either.
1 - 20 of 42 Posts
Join the discussion
