J or P ?

[james on bass]

Well, when I sell one of my fretless basses, it's time for another SX project.

I play classic rock covers, so either a Precision or Jazz would work, but I can't decide. The jazz is a bit more verstile, but the P is so simple and straight forward.

I'll be keeping one fretless and it is a Jazz.

Jazz bass in Vintage Yellow...

http://www.rondomusic.net/photos/bass/sjb57vyw1.jpg

or

Precision in Misty Silver...

http://www.rondomusic.net/photos/bass/spb57msl1.jpg

Either one will receive a tortoise shell pick guard.

[Xanadu]

I voted P. i like the looks better...
and you didnt include Ibby as an option.

[james on bass]

Despite the poll results, I think I'm going to pull the trigger on the P.

Hey Xanadu - looking for a fretless J? Sure you are.

[chrisgoodhue]

:DevilGuitar:

[nine]

I tend to enjoy the sweet, sweet thump of a P over the J.

Go P!

[Xanadu]

i saw your thread in the FS thread, and thought about it. But I'm saving up for a new computer, so no.:frown:

[james on bass]

i saw your thread in the FS thread, and thought about it. But I'm saving up for a new computer, so no.:frown:


well, feel free to throw me an offer if you change your mind.

[oddio]

Tiebreaker! At least for now.

[KevenK]

Sorry if it's in INCREDIBLY stupid question, but can someone tell me what's the difference between a Jazz and a Precision ?

Is it only the look ?

[james on bass]

The jazz has 2 single coil pickups, whereas the P has a single split pickup.

With the "real" Fender varieties, the jazz has a very slim neck and the P has a beefier neck.

In very simple terms tone-wise, a jazz is a bit more growly and the P bass has more of a thump to it with a little less bite.

[JBassJohn]

I voted for the P. Just because I already have a Jazz.

[mandocaster]

Can I vote for both?

I have a Precision body & guts with a Jazz neck. The best of both worlds.

[bassman blue]

Can I vote for both?

I have a Precision body & guts with a Jazz neck. The best of both worlds.


Yup, that's the cat's meow... or a nice P/J set up on a precision body/jazz neck or even a P/J on a Jazz body/Jazz neck...

[bluecoyote]

I had an American Fender Precision Deluxe for a number of years and just loved the sound but just hated the neck. The thing was incredibly heavy too. I wonder if the Jazz model is lighter. I am assuming that the neck is thinner. I should take a closer look.

[Milkman]

I like the P - J pickup configuration on a Jazz bass.

(bridge = P, neck = J)

Great flexibility. Plays like a dream.

[james on bass]

I like the P - J pickup configuration on a Jazz bass.

(bridge = P, neck = J)

Great flexibility. Plays like a dream.

Do you mean the other way around or are you talking totally custom? I've never seen a set-up like that.

[bluecoyote]

Do you mean the other way around or are you talking totally custom? I've never seen a set-up like that.

I saw and played a Fender Reggie Hamilton Jazz Bass that had that combination. Fine bass for just a real serious price!

[bluecoyote]

That has a J in the bridge and a P in the neck, which is quite a common configuaration for later-model P-basses. Never seen a P in the bridge and a J in the neck.

FWIW, I have a Jazz Bass that I quite enjoy. I bought it because I am a guitar player who once got a regular gig playing bass, and wanted something with a neck that felt similar to a guitar. If I were to dive into bass seriously, I'd probably get a P-bass, though. The J is nice. A good variety of tones to be had, and a very comfortable neck. I just love the sound of a P-bass, though.

You are right and I stand corrected. Then I have not seen a P in the bridge and a J in the neck. Are there any stock basses that offer that combination? What would be the sound advantages to that?

[Milkman]

Do you mean the other way around or are you talking totally custom? I've never seen a set-up like that.



No, sorry of course you're right. I meant P = neck. Brain fart. Thanks.None

[james on bass]

No, sorry of course you're right. I meant P = neck. Brain fart. Thanks.None


Not a problem. I was concerned that there was something out there I hadn't seen before. :tongue:

[james on bass]

That would be a great pickup combo!! Makes me want a BC Rich again.

[FenderMan]

I believe the proper response is "both" :food-smiley-004:

[BHarris]

I did just see Chad VanGaalen tonight, though, and has bass player had a J-bass with P-pickups in both the bridge and neck positions. I'd never seen that before.

I believe G&L makes one like that... was it a 'Fender' or just j-bass style?

[sartana]

Hell buyem both then you can't go wrong!!!!
Both awesome choices:food-smiley-004:

[GP_Hawk]

I'd say a Jazz because I have one and love it! Although right now it needs a new neck:frown: And yeh, being a guitar player mainly, I can appreciate the neck. Just fits me better.

[Greenman]

P/J pickup config is a good mod platform. I would want J body and neck and spend 175 bucks and get a Audere pre to fit your front route. I would also carefully route a battery cavity in the back just for ease of operation.:rockon2: